百科问答小站 logo
百科问答小站 font logo



法国在欧洲被慢慢边缘化了吗,德国正在取代法国成为欧陆的新「霸主」吗? 第1页

  

user avatar   gunter-schoech 网友的相关建议: 
      

As a German living in France, I think the question should be phrased the other way around "I France gaining weight in Europe at Germany's expense?"

Germany is dominating Europe in many ways, foremost economically.

It's ~1/3 bigger than that of France.

For quite some time now, France has been looking to Germany as example in many ways (justified or not). In the last presidential elections in France, this was a big theme.

Germany, under Chancellor Schröder a long time ago, had initiated reforms of the labor market under the label "Agenda 2010", citing the target year (this started ~5 years earlier).

Many attribute Germany's recent economic success to these reforms, some contest it. In any case, Germany had made some reforms, and France for a long time seemed unable to make any significant reforms. Too strong was the resistance from labor unions and any other special interest groups who feared change.

Under President Nicolas Sarkozy, reforms were planned, the President being eager to change his country. However, his lavish personal life style alienated the people, and he lost so much credibility that he could not succeed.

The last President, Francois Hollande, in my perception never really honestly tried to accomplish anything. He seemed quite happy with the fact he was President, and his "reforms" first went into the direction of his socialist party, and at a later stage into the opposite direction.

In total, many consider these 2 presidencies as wasted time.

The current President, Emmanuel Macron, has quite a number of ambitious plans, and much more dexterity in implementing things. His election gave new hope to a nation which seemed in resignation.
Most recently, the reforms are meeting resistance, e.g. from the railway operator, students and others. But that is normal. Any serious reform meets resistance.

The opposite is happening in Germany.

Chancellor Angelika Merkel is serving since 2000 !
She is now heading a "Grand Coalition" again of the 2 biggest German parties. While in theory, this would allow almost any reform, in reality it means political standstill.

The inner-German discussion currently circles around the "question", if Islam belongs to Germany or not. It's actually trivial. You look around yourself, and you see people of Islamic faith next to Germans. Many are from Turkey and the first generation came in the 1950's, their children and grand-children now play in our national soccer team. Some also came in the recent wake of refugees. And Germany is a secular state, where church and state are separated, and where we have freedom of religion. So its not an issue where you could do anything. Yet some politicians prefer to cause public upheaval around the topic, instead of doing their homework of major reforms.

This can also be observed on the European stage, where President Macron is pushing important projects for further unification of Europe (e.g. a European Finance Minister, a European Monetary Fund etc.). Germany is simply trying to preserve the status quo.

M. Macron knows many other European nations behind him, while Germany stands almost alone. If it were not for its great economic weight, the outcome would be clear.

Usually, it is the one who acts who defines what is being discussed. In Europe, that is much more France right now than Germany.




  

相关话题

  这几年到底发生了什么事使得菲律宾疏远美国,同时「倒向」中国? 
  如何评价新华社关于台积电南京扩产的评论文字:“世上没有速效救“芯”丸 ?” 你支持什么观点? 
  印度可以同时和俄罗斯和美国都做朋友吗? 
  为什么雷克萨斯在知乎上评价这么高? 
  德国海军总监称「普京应该得到尊重、克里米亚半岛已经永远失去了」,随后道歉并辞职,有哪些信息值得关注? 
  如何看待“给外部势力递刀”的说法? 
  林毅夫「中国未来 20 年还具有以 8% 的速度增长的潜力」是否有道理?为什么? 
  房地产税对房地产市场会有什么影响? 
  当下的中国追求「星辰大海」有什么错? 
  近代几乎一直维持着完整领土的法国人口为什么比割了东部的德国还要少? 

前一个讨论
什么事让你放弃了自杀的念头?
下一个讨论
既然台湾民进党的统治如此糟糕,为什么老百姓不推翻他们?





© 2025-05-02 - tinynew.org. All Rights Reserved.
© 2025-05-02 - tinynew.org. 保留所有权利