百科问答小站 logo
百科问答小站 font logo



自然科学领域,什么样的研究才算是有「好品位」? 第1页

  

user avatar   chirality 网友的相关建议: 
      

在American Physical Society News上看到过这么个好玩的文章,关于苹果砸中牛顿后的不同的科学品味导致的结果:

Good Science

1. Apple falls on Newton’s head.

2. Newton discovers Law of Universal Gravitation.

Bad Science

1. Apple falls on Newton’s head.

2. Newton publishes the following paper:

On the Impact of a 0.12 kg Apple with the Head

Isaac Newton

Fig. 1. Experimental Setup

Abstract. We have carried out an experimental study to determine quantitatively the risks faced by people standing under an apple tree. The Collision Induced Pain (CIP) produced by a 0.12 kg apple on the head was measured.

Introduction. Since the early days of Creation, Man has been interested in apples [1]. Its nutritive properties [2] as well as its potential toxicity have been thoroughly discussed [3]. More recently, apples have found important technological applications [4]. However, little attention has been given to the critical issue of the risks faced by the eventual fruit picker who approaches the branches of an apple tree.

Experimental procedure and results. An experiment was carried out to determine the effect of an apple falling on the head. The experimental setup is sketched in Fig. 1. The experimenter sat under an apple tree for five consecutive days and different intervals of time ∆t (Table 1). On the fifth day an apple fell on the experimenter’s head from a distance d=1.8±0.1 metres. The mass of the apple was found to be M=0.12±0.01 kg. Immediately after the collision the experimenter reported a mild discomfort that decreased exponentially with time as he rubbed his hand against the Apple Impact Area (AIA).

Table 1. Recorded events

On a scale of 0 to 10, the Collision Induced Pain (CIP) was rated as 2.3±0.1 (Fig. 2) and it decreased down to negligible values after a time τ=14.6±0.5 seconds. Some authors suggest that a more vigorous rubbing on the AIA would reduce substantially the Pain Relaxation Time (PRT) [5], although this theory has been highly disputed. No structural damage was observed in the experimenter’s skull.

Conclusion. A quantitative determination of the effect of an apple falling on the head was carried out for the first time. A 0.12 kg apple falling on the experimenter’s head from a distance of 1.8 metres was found to produce a CIP of 2.3±0.1 arbitrary units. A future development of this work includes the measurement of the CIP induced by apples of different mass and investigating the collision with pears. These studies will be carried out as soon as the author finds a PhD student as he is not very keen on repeating the experience himself.

FIG 2. Plot of the CIP as a function of apple mass (solid square, d=1.8 metres).

Acknowledgments. The author thanks the University of Cambridge (UK) for providing the apple tree. [1] Adam et al., Eden J. Nat. Hist. 1, 1 (8000 BC). [2] Granny Smith, “1000 recipes with apples”, Orchard Publishers, Appleville, 1964. [3] S. White and Seven Coauthors, J. Appl. Witchcraft A: Poisons 7, 2345 (1532). [4] Macintosh et al., J. Hort. Comput. 52, 2167 (1973). [5] Mrs. Newton, private communication.

Ed. Note: This Zero Gravity was contributed by Ricardo Torres of Imperial College. Since it is, essentially, a work of fiction, we hope our readers will indulge the author and forgive certain anachronisms and historical inaccuracies (e.g., the metric system had not been invented in Newton’s time, and the apple tree was in Newton’s home town of Woolsthorpe, not Cambridge).


好的品味当然是能透过现象,仔细观察进而思考到事物背后的本质,揭示相应的规律进而推动科学发展,而坏的品味现在基本打开任何一本杂志满眼皆是,都是灌水文章。


参考链接:Zero Gravity: The Lighter Side of Science




  

相关话题

  我想学可控核聚变,应该报哪个学校的哪个专业? 
  中国能否在二十年内,投入 3000 亿元,培养出十个本土的自然科学诺奖获得者?为此,需要做哪些改进? 
  物质会不会无限小呢?夸克也会有内部结构,然后这个内部结构依旧有更小的内部结构,无限细分? 
  在烹饪加工过程当中,那些食材(主要是面食,蔬菜)到底发生了什么变化?会让我们觉得它们熟了,而不是生的? 
  为什么由一堆化学物质组成的人具有思维?可能分析其成分并复制一个人吗? 
  硅基生命能否穿越硅酸盐为主的石头? 
  如果一根冰做的针,以高速穿过人的要害部位,能否将人致死而不被发现? 
  有人类基因就是人类吗? 
  在理论研究中,原始的点子更重要还是中间过程更重要? 
  上初三的女儿对我说,觉得学数学、化学、物理什么的都没有意义,我该怎么回答她? 

前一个讨论
如何看待饶毅说「证明你的研究不是体力而是智力活动的三种模式」,是其他人没有做/认为不重要?
下一个讨论
单身的人一般都在做什么?





© 2025-04-29 - tinynew.org. All Rights Reserved.
© 2025-04-29 - tinynew.org. 保留所有权利