怎样怼回审稿人的无理要求？ 第1页

如果不是特别坚定要 rej，这种顾左右而言他的批话一般是想诱导你去引他的工作，这种情况下直球辱骂他的工作即可。

We are surprised that “reviewer 2” decided to bring up this issue as it is a textbook example of how bad science is being propagated. Below we copy-paste the XXXX reported by XXX (ACS Catal. ****).

然后一通爆怼，把丫要求对比和引用的文章直接批倒批臭，最后：

We have obviously alerted the editor in chief of ACS Catalysis of this unethical behavior and the grove scientific flaws. We refuse to cite this publication. The reason we elaborate on this here is to also make the ACIE editorial office aware of the bad scientific practices by this group, as well as their delay tactics which we have experience now several times. Needless to say that we ask you to red flag“reviewer 2”. This person is incompetent, and we do not wish to be subjected to this level of review ever again.

极致嘴臭，极致享受。最后接收了，还是VIP。

可见，只要是有理有据，完全不需要因为害怕就去惯着这些老阴币，毕竟编辑是有脑子的……